Crystal Lake got us so hooked on Jason lore that we rewatched the whole franchise, Blu-ray box set and all. That’s 12 movies and two very different opinions.
We each ranked the films from 12 to 1, added our scores together, and let the math settle it. (If you want the Crystal Lake side of things, check out our full breakdown of the show’s lore.)
12. Jason Goes to Hell: The Final Friday (1993)
Arthur: #12 – Meaghan: #11

The only Friday the 13th movie of the entire 1990s kills Jason in the opening minutes, then lets his spirit jump from body to body looking for another Voorhees to bring him back.
Arthur didn’t hold back:
This is a filler movie.
Meaghan agrees it barely feels like a Friday film. Jason is hardly in it, the pacing is weird, and the whole thing seems to wish it were a different movie.
11. Friday the 13th Part VIII: Jason Takes Manhattan (1989)
Arthur: #10 – Meaghan: #12

A graduating class sails from Crystal Lake to New York, which raises the question nobody can answer: since when does a lake empty into New York Harbor? Arthur’s biggest gripe is right there in the title.
The whole movie’s not in Manhattan; it’s on a boat.
Meaghan calls it boring, packed with sad flashbacks to little-boy Jason, and says the dog was the real star.
10. Friday the 13th Part III (1982)
Arthur: #11 – Meaghan: #9

Part III exists because 3D was the hot thing, and it shows. The behind-the-scenes footage on our Blu-ray set confirmed what Arthur suspected; nobody cared about the story or the characters, only the effects.
Chris Higgins heading back to Higgins Haven should be a solid setup, but the strange hint about what Jason did to her years earlier sits badly with both of us. Meaghan ranks it a bit higher only because it’s so bad it becomes fun background viewing.
9. Friday the 13th Part VII: The New Blood (1988)
Arthur: #9 – Meaghan: #10

Jason versus Carrie, basically. Telekinetic Tina tries to bring her dead father back and accidentally wakes Jason from the bottom of the lake instead. The plot and side characters are rough, but the Tina vs. Jason fights rule.
Meaghan thinks this might be the best Jason ever looked (exposed spine, ribs, the chain around his neck), and she owns the figure to prove it. Arthur’s verdict: great looks, everything else, nope.
8. Friday the 13th: A New Beginning (1985)
Arthur: #8 – Meaghan: #8

We tied on this one, and Arthur admits he maybe should have gone lower since Jason isn’t actually the killer. The reveal is terrible.
Meaghan loves the side characters, though, especially Ethel and her chaotic son, and the messy direction makes it more entertaining than it has any right to be. Bonus fact from Arthur: Jason was almost named Josh, after one of Sean S. Cunningham’s kids.
Something with two syllables does sound better.
Meaghan decided.
7. Friday the 13th (2009)
Arthur: #5 – Meaghan: #5

Another tie, and we both liked the remake more than expected. Arthur relates to this survivalist Jason who “just wants to be left alone.”
Meaghan loved the kills and how it plays with your expectations twice: once with the opening group who aren’t the main cast, and once with who ends up as the final girl. Keep an eye on the tunnel for Easter eggs, including a wheelchair that might nod to Part 2.
Not Sure What to Watch?
Answer 4 questions, get curated horror movies to watch.
6. Friday the 13th: The Final Chapter (1984)
Arthur: #6 – Meaghan: #4

It was supposed to be the end, so everyone went all out. We get the debut of Tommy Jarvis (Corey Feldman), the charming Jarvis family, a great final kill, and Crispin Glover’s unscripted dance, which Arthur says makes it worth watching on its own.
Meaghan still quotes “Hey Ted, where’s the corkscrew?” for no reason at all. Jason actor, Ted White, in his late fifties, threatened to quit mid-production because the young cast was being mistreated during freezing December night shoots.
5. Jason X (2001)
Arthur: #3 – Meaghan: #6

Jason in space. Arthur is a sucker for sci-fi horror, so this was an easy sell, and he’ll happily half-watch it in the background. He calls the liquid nitrogen face smash “the coolest cool kill”.
Meaghan loves Uber Jason and the early 2000s Canadian sci-fi vibe, which makes it oddly comforting. Fun fact: Kane Hodder reportedly never blinks once as Jason.
4. Friday the 13th (1980)
Arthur: #2 – Meaghan: #7

The original is our biggest split. Arthur loves it for starting everything and introducing Camp Crystal Lake, which is a real place: Camp No-Be-Bo-Sco, a New Jersey Boy Scout camp running since 1927.
Meaghan calls Betsy Palmer iconic as Pamela, but she’s honest about the first 45 minutes being a slog. Arthur’s defense is that Cunningham was chasing Halloween’s success, and Halloween is slow too.
3. Friday the 13th Part VI: Jason Lives (1986)
Arthur: #7 – Meaghan: #1

Tommy brings Jason back as a supernatural zombie, and the franchise was never the same. It struggled on release after A New Beginning burned fans, but it has aged into a favorite.
Meaghan calls it half an action movie and loves the paintball group, the sarcastic grown-up Tommy, and a final girl named Megan who plays against type and survives.
Arthur adds that it’s the first entry where every “teenager” was actually an adult.
2. Freddy vs. Jason (2003)
Arthur: #4 – Meaghan: #3

Is this a Nightmare on Elm Street movie or a Friday the 13th movie? Put on the spot, Arthur said Freddy movie, and Meaghan agreed since Freddy pulls the strings the whole way.
It was her first taste of either franchise at 12 or 13, and she still rewatches it. The fights are top tier, even with some strange stuttery frame rate shots. The one thing we both hate? The idea that Jason is afraid of water.
1. Friday the 13th Part 2 (1981)
Arthur: #1 – Meaghan: #2

Our clear winner. Part 2 takes everything from the original and makes it faster and more fun, with characters who feel like real people. Ginny Field (Amy Steel) is one of Meaghan’s favorite final girls: sarcastic, resourceful, and smart enough to put on Pamela’s sweater and tell him, “Jason, mother is talking to you.”
Arthur loves the burlap sack and Jason finally being the killer. Bonus: costume designer Ellen Lutter played Jason’s legs in one shot, making her the only woman to ever play him.
